The tidiness of elementary mathematics: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen

Version vom 8. November 2011, 23:38 Uhr

We all expect a certain tidiness to mathematics, and for many this provides a gratifying aesthetic pleasure. However, there are some wrinkles. One of these arises in the integral of $x^k$ . Calculus provides us with the formula $\int x^k\mathrm{d}x = \frac{x^{k+1}}{k+1}.$ However, this equation is only correct for $k\neq -1$ . If we try to take $k=-1$ the right hand side is meaningless because we have a zero on the denominator of the fraction, i.e. $\frac{1}{0}$ . But in this case a separate argument gives the answer $\int x^{-1}\mathrm{d}x = \int \frac{1}{x}\mathrm{d}x = \ln(x).$

Our expectation is that these two formulae should be reconciled. Indeed, if we let $k$ approach $-1$ in the first we should end up with the second, but that fails to happen. For each $x$ , $\lim_{k\rightarrow -1} \frac{x^{k+1}}{k+1}$ is undefined.

This vingette explores this issue.

Main article

Applets

In this applet move the slider so that $k \rightarrow -1$ .

In this applet move the slider so that $n \rightarrow \infty$ .

@@ Zeile 11: / Zeile 11: @@
 == Applets ==
+In this applet move the slider so that <math>k \rightarrow -1</math>.
 <ggb_applet width="634" height="463"  version="4.0" ggbBase64="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" framePossible = "false" showResetIcon = "true" showAnimationButton = "true" enableRightClick = "false" errorDialogsActive = "true" enableLabelDrags = "false" showMenuBar = "false" showToolBar = "false" showToolBarHelp = "false" showAlgebraInput = "false" useBrowserForJS = "true" allowRescaling = "true" />
+In this applet move the slider so that <math>n \rightarrow \infty</math>.
 <ggb_applet width="634" height="463"  version="4.0" ggbBase64="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" framePossible = "false" showResetIcon = "true" showAnimationButton = "true" enableRightClick = "false" errorDialogsActive = "true" enableLabelDrags = "false" showMenuBar = "false" showToolBar = "false" showToolBarHelp = "false" showAlgebraInput = "false" useBrowserForJS = "true" allowRescaling = "true" />

The tidiness of elementary mathematics: Unterschied zwischen den Versionen

Version vom 8. November 2011, 23:38 Uhr

Main article

Applets

Navigationsmenü

Meine Werkzeuge

Namensräume

Varianten

Ansichten

Aktionen

Suche

Navigation

Werkzeuge